Since Donald Trump’s inauguration many of America’s allies have been careful with their words showing little public criticism. However his recent proposal about Gaza has shattered this delicate balance. Trump’s idea of taking control of Gaza relocating Palestinians and transforming it into a luxury destination has shocked not only the region but also the West. This plan goes against decades of established policies especially the two state solution that has been the backbone of Western diplomacy in the region.

Leaders across the globe from Europe to the Middle East have strongly opposed this suggestion. The European Union the United Nations and several Western nations have condemned the proposal arguing it would violate international law and lead to further suffering. While the criticism has been sharp many leaders are hesitant to openly rebuke the US due to their deep ties with the country and the potential fallout of antagonizing the administration too early in Trump’s second term.

The issue has placed America’s allies in a difficult position. Many are wary of Trump’s unpredictability but openly criticizing him could damage vital relationships. Nations like Germany France and Spain have made their disapproval clear while Britain has walked a fine line trying to maintain a good relationship with the US especially with ongoing trade talks. In contrast far-right figures like Geert Wilders in the Netherlands have supported Trump’s controversial idea showing the divisions in Europe over this issue.

Trump’s aggressive foreign policy approach has already begun to alienate some traditional allies who now face tough questions about how to engage with an America that seems increasingly isolationist and less committed to multilateralism. His policies including withdrawing from international agreements and weakening US agencies like USAID have created an environment where countries are considering alternative alliances particularly with Russia and China.

As this new wave of conflict and uncertainty unfolds many worry that Trump’s policies if left unchecked could further isolate the US and diminish its global influence. The situation in Gaza alongside Trump’s handling of other geopolitical issues like the Ukraine crisis will likely continue to test the limits of international diplomacy.